Comparing Axle Types

(Article begins on the Tech, Tests & Installs page HERE)

About Different Axle Designs

Flange Axle Design - The most common flange axle design has a single piece axle, flange and shaft. The axle bearing has a press fit on to the axle shaft and a bearing lock ring is then pressed on behind the bearing. Housing ends are welded to the housing tube and the bearing slips into the housing end. The bearing is then retained by the caliper mounting bracket. Wheel studs are installed in the flange of the axle where the wheel bolts directly to the outside of the axle flange. With this design the axle and axle bearings must support not only the vehicle’s weight and torsional loads, but also the bending loads from acceleration (rear wheels try to “toe-in” during acceleration).

Safety - In the event of an axle failure the axle along with the wheel and tire can separate from the vehicle. In the case of a break outboard of the bearing, the wheel will definitely come off. A break inboard of the bearing and the wheel will stay on only until the caliper mount breaks and the bearing is free to come out of the housing end. This will also take out the rear brakes and the caliper and brake lines will be torn off.



Full Floater Design - The full floater design incorporates a hub with a bearing installed in each end. Wheel studs are installed into this hub and the assembled hub is then slipped on to the floater spindle. The floater spindle is then welded to the housing tube. The floater spindles are tubular and are large enough for the axle shaft to pass through. The drive plate is splined in the center and slides over the wheel studs and seats against the hub. The axle shaft is splined on both ends, one end engages the drive plate and the other end engages spool in the thirdmember. With a full floater the axle shaft only sees torsional loads since the wheel and tire are bolted to the floater hubs, which are independent of the axle shaft. All other loads are taken in the hubs and floater spindles

Safety - In the event of an axle failure the wheel and tire will remain with the vehicle (as stated earlier the axle is independent of the flange and hub which are mounted on the floater spindle). The rear brakes would not be affected by axle breakage.


Live Axle Design - With this design the axle shaft is a large diameter, thin wall tube and becomes more of a structural member. The shaft is splined in the center to engage the spool and splined on both ends to accept a splined flange on each end. Both ends have a threaded area for the flange retaining nut. Most live axles use a single tapered roller bearing on each end, which must be preloaded with the flange retaining nuts during assembly. This design is most commonly found in Top Fuel car applications. With this design the axle shaft must carry all the load.

Safety - As is the case with the flange axle, in the event of an axle failure (unlikely due to the size of the axle) the wheel and tire can separate from the vehicle. This would also take out the rear brakes and the caliper and brake lines would be torn off.


 

Source:
Mark Williams Enterprises
www.MarkWilliams.com